Freedom of Speech! Well you read that right. It's that one
fundamental right that has been bestowed upon us as a part of a social
agreement between us and the state, or even simply put, the basic rights you
get from the Government, which by the way, is run based on our votes. A lot has
been happening lately, and before I went ahead and posted my opinions
about any issue, I had to get my facts right. You ask me why? Well, for starters,
nothing will ever be truly lost on the internet, and I want to leave the right
impression behind.
Life, as we know
it, has changed a great deal since the internet came around. And with Life, it
also changed the way we looked at it, and the way we expressed our gratitude,
dissent, love, hate, and perspectives. Our views are no longer limited to our
friends circle, once on the internet, EVERYONE is going to read it. So what
happens when one person, or a group of persons, goes ahead and preaches, what may
be their own Utopian concept of the way we're supposed to be living, EVERYONE
reads it, and that sets the House
Of Cards rolling down.
Patriotism, as a concept, is in itself very self defeating. Or at least that is
what I believe. And as you may reasonably
foresee, I believe Nationalism is a fad too. And to explain the same, I'll
direct the rest of this article. These views are definitely not influenced by
the biased media, or the supposedly unbiased student movements in India. So!
Read on to see how I've tried to strike a balance between Activism, Blind
Patriotism, and apparently Extremism.
As of 2013, India
houses 1.252 Billion people. And trust me when I say this, You can't expect all
of them to have the same outlook towards a problem or an issue. Some of the
recent incidents which bring this to light are the JNU Fiasco, The Hyderabad
University- Rohith Vemula Case, and even the Haryana Riots! As the situation
stands, it is indeed safe to say India isn't the only country facing a similar
issue. European Countries facing the Immigrants Transfer Issues, America having
its own sweet time with a Fascist Donald Trump, and China's South China Sea
dispute, all have a key factor tying all of them together. Excessive Love for
one's country, Lack of Trust in others' countries, Believing that ones country
is truly the best one that there is, which one could also believe to be
borderline Jingoistic Behavior.
While one side of the story rests heavily on the fact that since
we are citizens of this country, we have every right to criticise the way we
work; The other side rests on the fact that the means adopted to criticise are
neither fair or acceptable. While we are at this, It should also be highlighted
that hasty generalisation has led to a lot of students being caught in
crossfire. While the media is busy covering what one politician had to say
about Condoms being found in the Campus, social media was abuzz with updates
from students who were frisked just for uttering the words J.N.U. Agreed that
the actions of the students might have been a little too extreme, but how do
you justify generalising a factions actions as the whole student fraternity’s
actions? Personally, I do have my reservations about why someone would yell
anti-national slogans, but I also understand that these Universities are
supposed to do the same! No, not make anti nationals, but rouse curiosity,
spread knowledge, and quash ignorance.
While I was completing my research on this issue, I happened to
stroll across a brilliantly crafted speech by the HRD Minister, but well, even
that has a loophole. It selectively picks on some students who have vandalised
our fabled gods and goddesses and their backstories. She incisively uses these
examples and then shifts attention to the other issues, of Caste and Race.
Having felt the heat and aftermath of the Riots myself, I can definitely tell
you it was a means too extreme to an ends too biased. People who love their
caste so much and identify themselves by it, are, on a microscale, the same as
Nationalists! Going by this logic, all our freedom fighters were extremists
too, and as I read somewhere, Our Beloved Tagore would have been jailed for
Anti- National Songs!
There were indeed other incidents being highlighted by these so
called Anti-Nationals, and one of the most controversial issues was Indian
Army's brutality in Kashmir. A quick google search would lead one to the Kunan Poshpora
Incident, which I'd suggest readers to look up for themselves. Yet
again this strand of their debate is highly specific, and targets a specific
section of the Army, and quite frankly speaking, they are right when they say
they have the right to criticize the way our country works. While this view is
from a layman's standpoint, the very same negligibly knowledgeable Layman would
praise the same Military's quick response in times of natural disasters. Their
rescue operations are generally front page headlines, and it's not that easy to
turn a deaf ear to these heroics. Not just at times such as that, any call of
distress has the same army walk in to save the nation's public, from threats
both external and internal. While I've been a firsthand witness to the
reliability of the Army, (Rapid Action Force + Army= Safety from Haryana
Riots + Immense Respect for their Sacrifices) I can't not notice the
AFSPA- The Armed Forces Special Powers Act.While I may not have the standing of
a learned diplomat, I do have a fair understanding that this very same act
derives its origins from an Act which was framed to curb the Quit India Movement. And as it may be, I don't agree
with how such power can be put in the Army's hands without a proper system in
place to check on the possible violations that could be caused due to them.
Which brings me to another critical cog in the wheel of Justice and Good
Governance, The Legislative. But before we move on, think for a minute, Are all
the soldiers in the Indian Armed Forces Patriots? Or are they Nationalists? Or
even worse, Jingoists? Well, the answer may vary for different people, but one
can't simply write them off because a small faction resorted to grave lows.
Action needs to be taken. But to what degree?
The Legislative in India, is more a mockery of family lines than
anything at the first look. I don't understand what one of these new generation
Princes is doing by going out and announcing the present government doesn't
care about people's voices, while it was his own government that set the
criminal to a death penalty. The criminal in question is the same one that
sparked the JNU row. While this was happening, Riots broke out in another part
of India, and the supreme power, was actually concentrating on some scheme
regarding cows. How can one be so proud of a country that is riddled by such
problems? And why is it that Human Curiosity and Criticism is now being
Punished? And Yet Again! Why is it that we see students taking to roads to
achieve their means? It is indeed a tough task to make sure that all peoples of
this nation are served what they need, but why is it that Violence is being
used as a means to achieve that end?
Yes! Patriotism, In The Era of Internet, is nothing like what it
used to be years ago. This very same Internet once toppled governments,
restored democracy, but why is it that today, it's pushing us into the
darkness? If it can topple, It Can resurrect too. It is indeed very easy to
pick a side. #IstandwithJNU (or) #ShutDownJNU, these two phrases are the
two extreme sides of the same coin. While one side has a few that show utter
disregard to what the country has to offer, the other side has ridiculous
fanatics who'll tie any dirty laundry to a genuine question to make it sound
bad. Am I a Patriot? Maybe Yes, Maybe No. And what side do I pick to stand
with? I choose to stand with the side of Freedom. Words these days spread
faster and are also misinterpreted even faster so.
I am a Citizen of India. I do love my country. And I definitely am
not blind to not see that there's a lot wrong with this country. But I do know
something for sure. If I was born anyplace else, I may not have felt the same.
And to deal with the wrongs of a few, I wouldn't drag the country to a shame.
Satyamev Jayate.
Great writing...but how much ever we talk about these issues nothing's going to change.
ReplyDelete10-15 din chalega,log bhool jayenge.